SA #3: MTUM – Momentum, But Somewhat Slow

MTUM: Momentum, But Somewhat Slow
December 28, 2022

Summary

  • Momentum is one of the best-researched systematic investing strategies, and has provided significant outperformance in the past.
  • The MTUM ETF tracks the MSCI USA Momentum SR Variant Index and is an easy way to add momentum to a portfolio.
  • The ETF follows a transparent methodology and has performed mostly in line with the academic momentum benchmark from Kenneth French since 2013.
  • The key problem of the methodology, however, is the slow, six-month rebalancing – also the reason why MTUM suffered in 2022.
  • For investors who don’t want to take too much active risk and/or monitor active managers, the MTUM ETF is still a reasonable momentum implementation.


Read the Full Article on Seeking Alpha

Read the Full Post

AgPa #34: Inefficient Christmas Gifts

The Deadweight Loss of Christmas (1993)
Joel Waldfogel
The American Economic Review 83(5), 1328-1336, URL

Welcome to the Christmas edition! As a rare exception, this AGNOSTIC Paper is not about finance and investing. Instead, we will look at the economics of Christmas gifts…

  • Many non-cash gifts are economically inefficient
  • The deadweight loss of Christmas is in the billions

Read the Full Post

AgPa #33: World Cups and Stock Markets

Sports Sentiment and Stock Returns (2007)
Alex Edmans, Diego García and Øyvind Norli
The Journal of Finance 62(4), 1967-1998, URL

Given that this week’s AGNOSTIC Paper coincides with the final of the World Cup, I couldn’t resist the temptation. Below you can see a chart of the knockout stage of this year’s tournament. But since you are visiting a nerdy finance website, the focus is not on the results, but on the post-match stock market returns of the playing countries…


You may (understandably) say that this is some nice storytelling but not much more. However, I didn’t made this up to create a story but the idea of this analysis actually comes from this week’s AGNOSTIC paper…

  • Stock markets of losing countries tend to underperform after important matches
  • The effect most likely comes from bad mood after sport losses

Read the Full Post

AgPa #32: Agnostic Fundamental Analysis (3/3)

Boosting agnostic fundamental analysis: Using machine learning to identify mispricing in European stock markets (2022)
Matthias X.Hanauer, Marina Kononova, Marc Steffen Rapp
Finance Research Letters 48, URL/SSRN

The third and final post about agnostic fundamental analysis. This week’s AGNOSTIC Paper challenges the simple linear methodology and introduces vastly improved valuation models…

  • More sophisticated valuation models yielded better performance
  • Different models emphasize different fundamental variables

Read the Full Post

AgPa #31: Agnostic Fundamental Analysis (2/3)

Global market inefficiencies (2021)
Söhnke M. Bartram, Mark Grinblatt
Journal of Financial Economics 139(1), 234-259, URL/SSRN

The second AGNOSTIC Paper on agnostic fundamental analysis. This one is the international out-of-sample test where the authors apply their methodology to stock markets around the world. The results point in the same direction and suggest robust out-of-sample evidence…

  • Undervalued stocks outperformed overvalued stocks – also globally
  • Agnostic fundamental analysis yielded significant alpha – globally and against up to 80 factors
  • Agnostic fundamental analysis remains profitable after transaction costs
  • The degree of market efficiency differs around the world

Read the Full Post

AgPa #30: Agnostic Fundamental Analysis (1/3)

Agnostic fundamental analysis works (2018)
Söhnke M. Bartram, Mark Grinblatt
Journal of Financial Economics 128(1), 125-147, URL/SSRN

This week’s AGNOSTIC Paper tackles a very basic question: Does fundamental analysis work? For that purpose, the authors introduce an agnostic valuation model that explains the market capitalization of companies by their most recent fundamentals. A strategy that bets on the convergence of prices and estimated “fair” values generated strong profits between 1987 and 2012…

  • Undervalued stocks outperformed overvalued stocks by about 0.5% per month
  • Agnostic fundamental analysis yielded significant alpha

Read the Full Post

SA #2: QMOM – A Close Look At The Methodology

QMOM: A Close Look At The Methodology
November 20, 2022

Summary

  • Momentum is one of the best-researched systematic investing strategies and produced significant outperformance in the past.
  • Over the last 5 years, the QMOM ETF outperformed the academic benchmark from Kenneth French and several other momentum ETFs.
  • The QMOM ETF achieved this by a differentiated momentum-investment process, which I will analyze in this article.
  • The QMOM ETF delivered momentum exposure and helps to add momentum to basically all portfolios.


Read the Full Article on Seeking Alpha

Read the Full Post

SA #1: MSCI – Even Quality Can Become Too Expensive

MSCI: Even Quality Can Become Too Expensive
November 9, 2022

Summary

  • On October 25, MSCI reported quite strong 9M numbers and, for the moment, defended its high multiples (LTM P/E about 44).
  • In this article, I focus on a high-level valuation of MSCI to decide if it’s worth analyzing the stock in more detail.
  • Using a standard DCF-WACC model, market data for interest rates, and reasonable estimates for future fundamentals suggests massive overvaluation (theoretical downside of 54%).
  • The result is very similar when comparing MSCI to common valuation multiples of a peer group. Depending on the multiple, the company trades at a premium of up to 60%.
  • MSCI is undeniably a very high-quality company. But at the current levels, the company just appears way too expensive. So I am not yet interested.


Read the Full Article on Seeking Alpha

Read the Full Post

Seeking Alpha: Introduction

A few days ago, I published my first exclusive article on Seeking Alpha.

Given that Seeking Alpha has a lot of active visitors, it is a great way to build an audience for AgnosticInvesting.com. This comes at the cost that exclusive articles, as the name suggests, are only available on Seeking Alpha and you may need a premium subscription to read them.

Fortunately, however, I am still allowed to post short summaries here on my own website. You will find them under this category.

Read the Full Post

AgPa #29: Cost-Mitigation Techniques

Comparing Cost-Mitigation Techniques (2019)
Robert Novy-Marx, Mihail Velikov
Financial Analysts Journal 75(1), 85-102, URL/SSRN

This week’s AGNOSTIC Paper examines three techniques to mitigate trading costs of systematic equity strategies and compares them by after-cost performance. The empirical evidence clearly speaks for the application of more sophisticated trading rules (Technique #3)…

  • Trading costs decreased but are still important
  • Technique #1: focus on “cheap-to-trade” securities
  • Technique #2: rebalance less frequently
  • Technique #3: create better trading rules
  • Value- versus equal-weighted portfolios

Read the Full Post